Who is the Strongest Among Libra, Gemini, and Virgo Gold Saints?

Within the legendary ranks of Athena’s Gold Saints, twelve warriors stand at the absolute peak of power. These men, having mastered the Seventh Sense, are virtually unmatched in the mortal world. Yet, a timeless debate persists among fans: if these titans were to clash, who would truly reign supreme? While their power levels are often depicted as comparable, leading to the mythical “Thousand-Day War” stalemate, subtle distinctions in feats, stability, and narrative roles suggest a hierarchy. Today, we delve into the epicenter of this debate, analyzing the three most frequently cited contenders for the title: the stalwart Libra Dohko, the mercurial Gemini Saga, and the transcendent Virgo Shaka.

The Case for Libra Dohko: The Veteran’s Might

Often overlooked in raw power discussions, Libra Dohko presents a unique and compelling argument for the top spot. His greatest asset is not just power, but immense, refined experience. Having lived for over 250 years while watching over the seal of the 108 Specters, his Cosmos has been tempered and expanded across centuries. Even an average fighter would become formidable with that much time, but Dohko was a prodigy, (exceptionally promoted) in his youth.

Critically, he possesses the ability to revert to his 18-year-old physical prime, a state where his power, speed, and stamina would be at their absolute zenith. This isn’t mere speculation; the narrative of the Hades Chapter hinges on his immense strength. The entire plot to revive the Gold Saints for the assault on the Wailing Wall required his old rival, Aries Shion, to be his equal. This deliberate matchup by the author underscores that Dohko’s power is a foundational pillar of the Saints’ strength, making him, in many respects, the bedrock of the Gold Saints and a worthy candidate for the strongest of his generation.

The Gemini Enigma: Saga’s Divided Power

Gemini Saga is synonymous with devastating, universe-threatening power. His signature technique, the Galaxian Explosion, is arguably one of the most destructive attacks in the entire series. However, his greatest strength is also his greatest weakness: his fractured psyche. Saga’s power is intrinsically linked to his state of mind.

When consumed by his evil persona, he is an unstoppable force of nature—ruthless, cunning, and operating at a terrifying capacity. This “blackened” Saga truly earns the title of “the man who could destroy the universe.” However, once he is redeemed and fights with a clear, just conscience, his performance becomes noticeably less dominant. His power level seems to fluctuate, lacking the consistency of his peers. This instability, while not diminishing his peak potential, prevents him from reliably holding the number one position. He is the ultimate wild card: capable of defeating anyone on a bad day, but not the steady, unwavering pinnacle.

Virgo Shaka: The Man Closest to God

If Saga represents chaotic, destructive power, then Virgo Shaka represents transcendent, divine order. His epithet, “The Man Closest to God,” is not merely for show. Shaka’s strength is not just in his overwhelming techniques like the Tenma Kōfuku (Demon Pacifier) but in his profound understanding of the cosmos and the universe itself.

His most famous feat solidifies his claim. During the Hades Chapter, it took the combined effort of three Gold Saints—Saga, Cancer Deathmask, and Capricorn Shura—to defeat him using the Athena Exclamation. Even then, he was on the verge of stripping them of their five senses. This battle is less about raw power and more about a qualitative difference in existence; he operated on a nearly spiritual plane they struggled to comprehend.

Furthermore, the narrative itself treats him differently. Both he and the immensely powerful Dohko were sidelined early in the invasion of the Underworld. Many interpret this as a necessary plot device; their presence would have too easily tipped the scales against the forces of Hades, leading to Shaka being chosen for the critical task of delivering a message to Athena directly. His power is consistently portrayed as stable, profound, and of a higher dimension, making him the most consistently powerful and spiritually advanced of the Gold Saints.

Verdict: A Hierarchy of Power

So, who is the strongest? The answer lies in defining the terms.

• Peak Destructive Potential: Gemini Saga (evil persona) might hold a slight edge with the Galaxian Explosion.
• Experience and Strategic Depth: Libra Dohko in his prime is the unparalleled master, a warrior honed by centuries.
• Overall Consistent Power & Transcendence: Virgo Shaka stands alone. His feats, title, and the narrative weight given to his power position him as the most reliably powerful and spiritually evolved Gold Saint.

While the debate will rage on among fans, the evidence from the manga’s most crucial arc points to Virgo Shaka as the pinnacle of what a Gold Saint can achieve, a warrior who transcended mere combat to touch the divine. His combination of unparalleled defensive and offensive techniques, coupled with his cosmic awareness, ultimately gives him the edge in this celestial showdown.