Saint Seiya: Who Was Stronger – Virgo or Gemini in The Lost Canvas? My Take
The eternal debate between Asmita (Virgo) and Aspros (Gemini) in Saint Seiya: The Lost Canvas mirrors the classic Shaka versus Saga discussion from the original series – it’s a conversation without a definitive conclusion. Unlike Shaka and Saga who had direct confrontations, Asmita and Aspros never truly faced off, making their power comparison even more complex and speculative.
The Pope Temple Incident: A Study in Unresolved Tensions
During the Aspros rebellion at the Pope Temple, four powerful figures stood present: Aspros, Asmita, Defteros, and Sage. The dynamics were intriguing – Aspros confronted Sage while Asmita faced Defteros. Yet, despite the tense atmosphere, no full-scale battle erupted.
Sage found himself restrained by Aspros, while Asmita’s contribution was primarily dispelling the Galaxian Explosion that Aspros had cast upon Defteros. The dramatic conclusion came when Defteros delivered an unexpected blow that defeated Aspros. This encounter reveals little about comparative strength – Defteros defeating Aspros doesn’t prove superiority, just as Asmita breaking the Galaxian Explosion doesn’t demonstrate dominance over Aspros.
The Pope’s Perspective and Strategic Deployment
What’s particularly telling is Sage’s decision to deploy Asmita specifically to counter both Aspros and Defteros. This strategic choice suggests that in Sage’s assessment, Asmita possessed sufficient power to contend with the Gemini twins, indicating a level of respect for the Virgo Gold Saint’s capabilities that shouldn’t be overlooked in this comparison.
Against the Mightiest Specters: A Comparative Analysis
When examining their performances against the strongest Specters, patterns emerge. Aspros faced Kālvaka of the Star of Thanatos, widely considered among the most powerful entities in Hades’ army aside from the Twin Gods themselves. The battle demonstrated Kalvaka’s overwhelming superiority, with Aspros being consistently dominated until he employed the God’s Passage technique, effectively resetting the playing field.
Meanwhile, Asmita confronted the equally formidable Earth Spirit. While both Specters represented tremendous challenges, many observers note that Asmita appeared to handle his opponent with slightly more composure and control compared to Aspros’ struggle against Kalvaka.
The Intangible Factor: Presence and Dominance
Beyond technical combat capabilities, there’s an undeniable quality of presence that factors into these comparisons. Aspros carried himself with an aura of majesty and authority that few Gold Saints could match. This commanding presence, this innate sense of dominance, often translates into combat effectiveness that transcends mere technical skill.
Gemini Saints traditionally embody this regal, powerful energy that makes them natural leaders and formidable opponents. The Gemini constellation’s association with duality means they often possess both incredible offensive capabilities and strategic depth that makes them uniquely dangerous.
The Verdict: Why I Lean Toward Gemini’s Superiority
After examining all available evidence and considering the intangible qualities each Gold Saint possessed, I maintain that Aspros represented the more powerful warrior. While Asmita’s spiritual enlightenment and connection to the cosmic consciousness cannot be understated, the raw, overwhelming power and commanding presence of the Gemini Gold Saint ultimately tips the scales in his favor.
The Gemini constellation’s mythological associations with immense power, duality, and sometimes destructive potential aligns with what we witnessed from Aspros. His ability to nearly overthrow the Sanctuary’s leadership and challenge multiple Gold Saints simultaneously speaks to a level of capability that, while matched in different ways by Asmita, ultimately represents a more overt and immediately formidable combat presence.
What’s your perspective on this eternal debate? Which qualities do you value more in a Gold Saint – the spiritual mastery of Virgo or the overwhelming power of Gemini?
