Saint Seiya 3D Animation’s Absurd Original Plot: Milo Defeated in One Move by Phantom Gemini

The Saint Seiya 3D animation series continues to surprise fans with its controversial original content. While producers claim these additions “fill plot holes” from the original series, most viewers recognize them as unnecessary power inconsistencies that disrupt the established lore. The latest episode’s bizarre creative decision has left the community baffled: Milo of Scorpio, one of Gold Saints, being instantly defeated by a phantom Gemini clone.

Questionable Narrative Choices

The 3D remake has significantly amplified June’s role, elevating her to near-main-character status with excessive screen time. In this particular scene, June encounters Milo and reveals the truth about the Pope’s identity. Initially skeptical, Milo’s recent battle with Hyoga leaves him mentally vulnerable and open to doubt—a psychological state that the phantom Gemini exploits perfectly.

The Gemini Phantom’s Dominance

Without hesitation, Milo attacks with his signature Scarlet Needle, only to have it effortlessly countered and reflected back. Though he dodges his own technique, he fails to evade the Gemini phantom’s follow-up attack: the Another Dimension technique that instantly incapacitates him. This portrayal contradicts established power levels, especially considering Milo was at full strength—unlike previous scenarios where characters were weakened from prior battles.

Undermining Character Credibility

This scene fundamentally disrupts the power balance respected in the original series. While Saga later compliments Milo’s Scarlet Needle technique, this feels like a hollow consolation after such a disproportionate defeat. Long-time fans will recall that during the Hades Chapter, Saga himself falls victim to these very needles—while Milo faces the far more devastating Galaxian Explosion. The animation studio’s decision to weaken Milo here feels like an unjustified deviation from character integrity.

Gemini’s Mystique: Power Beyond Physical Form

This incident highlights the terrifying potential of the Gemini constellation’s power—even when manifested through a remote-controlled phantom. Gemini Saints possess not just immense cosmic energy, but also psychological manipulation capabilities that make them unpredictable adversaries. Their ability to project power across distances and through proxies speaks to their strategic genius and metaphysical connection to space-time manipulation, traits that make them among the most feared Gold Saints.

While the execution may be flawed, this scene inadvertently emphasizes the Gemini’s signature traits: duality, illusion mastery, and overwhelming force. It serves as a reminder that in the world of Saint Seiya, psychological warfare often determines victory more than pure strength—a lesson even experienced warriors like Milo must sometimes learn painfully.